The People God Uses: Peter (Failing Forward)
“Failure is simply the opportunity to begin again, this time more intelligently.” — Henry Ford
“Feed my sheep.” — John 21:17
If I were choosing someone to lead the early church, I'm not sure Peter would have been my first choice.
Peter talks too much.
He acts before thinking.
He misunderstands Jesus repeatedly.
He sinks while walking on water.
He argues with Jesus.
He cuts off someone's ear.
And when Jesus needs him most, Peter denies even knowing him.
Three times.
That's not exactly a stellar leadership record.
And yet Jesus keeps choosing Peter.
I identify with Peter more than most biblical characters. I get him to a certain extent because I often act impetuously, say and do the wrong things, and generally stumble around trying to follow Jesus.
For this reason, I'm so glad Peter's story doesn't end with his denial.
After the resurrection, Jesus meets Peter beside the Sea of Galilee.
They eat breakfast together.
Then Jesus asks:
“Do you love me?”
Peter says yes.
“Feed my sheep.”
Jesus asks again.
Then again.
Three denials.
Three questions.
Three invitations to begin again.
Jesus doesn't pretend Peter didn't fail.
But neither does Jesus allow Peter's failure to become his identity.
That matters.
Because most of us have been taught to think of success and failure as opposites.
Success means we're moving forward.
Failure means we're moving backward.
But sometimes failure becomes the place where we learn what success could never teach us.
Failure can make us humbler.
Kinder.
More patient.
Less judgmental.
More dependent upon grace.
Peter who had never failed might have become an insufferable church leader.
Peter who had failed knew exactly what it felt like to need forgiveness.
Maybe that's part of why Jesus could trust him with people.
We don't have to celebrate our failures.
Some failures hurt us.
Some hurt other people.
Some require apologies, repentance, consequences, and repair.
But failure doesn't have to be wasted.
God can use even the places where we got it wrong.
The question isn't whether you have failed.
You have.
So have I.
The question is what happens next.
Jesus doesn't ask Peter to spend the rest of his life staring backward at the courtyard where he failed.
He points Peter forward.
“Feed my sheep.”
There is still work to do.
There are still people to love.
There is still life ahead.
Grace doesn't mean failure doesn't matter. Grace means failure doesn't get to decide what happens next.
May you realize that you are not defined by your worst moments, but by God. May you embrace this and be at peace.
And may the grace and peace of our Lord Jesus Christ be with you all, now and forever. Amen.
Prayer
God of second chances, you know where I have failed. Give me humility to admit my mistakes, courage to repair what I can, and grace to forgive myself for what I cannot change. Teach me through my failures and help me believe that you still have something for me to do. Amen.
Reflection Questions
- What failure has taught you the most about yourself?
- Has a past failure made you more compassionate toward others?
- Where might God be saying to you, “There is still something for you to do”?

Comments
Post a Comment
Thanks for leaving a comment! If you comment Anonymously, your comment will summarily be deleted.